Cake Technical Information

Introduction

Cake is a comprehensive queue management system, implemented as a queue discipline (qdisc) for the Linux kernel. It is designed to replace and improve upon the complex hierarchy of simple qdiscs presently required to effectively tackle the bufferbloat problem at the network edge.

For installation and configuration instructions, please see the main Cake page.

Philosophy

Cake’s fundamental design goal is perceived simplicity. This is achieved by integrating lots of functionality into one qdisc, resulting in:

  • Information sharing between functional components, improving latency performance.
  • Eliminated message-passing overhead (improving throughput performance), and unmanaged queuing between qdiscs.
  • Greatly simplified configuration for common use-cases, compared to building equivalent functionality using existing qdiscs.

Cake is logically arranged as several layers of functionality:

  • Shaper
  • Priority queue
  • Flow isolation
  • AQM
  • Packet management

Each of the above layers is based on state-of-the-art techniques, many of which have improvements not previously realised. These are briefly explained below.

Additionally, most calculations are now performed on a time basis, with the remainder on a bytes basis. This is a fundamental improvement over many qdiscs which count only packets, which in practice vary greatly in size.

Shaper

Cake’s shaper is not a token bucket filter (TBF). It operates in deficit mode, which is essentially the opposite way to how a TBF works.

A major drawback of TBFs is that they require the bucket size to be configured explicitly. This not only runs counter to Cake’s goal of perceived simplicity, but limits latency performance in the typical Cake application, immediately upstream of a bottleneck link’s dumb FIFO. On flow startup, a TBF will dump the contents of its bucket into the FIFO immediately, so the rate of the TBF must be reduced significantly below the link rate in order to let the FIFO drain. Meanwhile, latency suffers proportionally to the size of the bucket.

Cake instead schedules packets based on time deficits. If no deficit exists when a packet is requested, it can be sent immediately. The transmit time of the following packet is then calculated, and until that time the shaper is placed in deficit mode. While in deficit mode, packets are scheduled using a watchdog timer whenever a request arrives too soon, and transmission times are calculated for a continuous packet train. This continues until the queue drains; if a packet is requested, but none are available and the next transmission time has been reached, the shaper returns to the quiescent state in which the next packet can be sent immediately.

Deficit mode makes the burst size dependent only on hardware and kernel latency (including timer resolution), and minimises bursts without requiring manual tuning. Cake’s shaper can therefore be set much closer to the actual link speed without jeopardising latency performance. Modern hardware can achieve sub-millisecond bursts in most cases.

CPU efficiency is also improved by inverting the user’s “bytes per time” setting into a “time per byte” measurement, so that the packet scheduling operation is essentially a multiply-accumulate rather than involving a division. This is implemented using a manual floating-point representation (mantissa and shift) for maximum precision and dynamic range. This contributes to improved throughput on low-end CPUs.

Priority Queue

Diffserv is poorly specified, and not widely deployed outside environments where Highly Paid Consultants are available to set it up. Cake’s priority layer aims to improve that situation by making a basic yet robust Diffserv-based priority queue available with no end-user effort. Hopefully, application support will follow.

Cake provides four traffic classes by default, nominally corresponding to the four classes provided by 802.11e and 801.2p. However, the precise mapping between Diffserv codepoints (DSCPs) and traffic classes is different. In increasing order of nominal priority:

  • Bulk, with no bandwidth threshold
  • Best Effort, with 1516 bandwidth threshold
  • Video, with 34 bandwidth threshold
  • Voice, with 14 bandwidth threshold

Most traffic falls into the Best Effort class. VoIP, NTP and gaming traffic should be directed to the Voice class, BitTorrent should be directed to the Bulk class, and the Video class is available for any bulk traffic that requires elevated priority.

Cake implements soft admission control, and so is robust against starvation attacks relying on strict priority, which would otherwise be easy to trigger by accident. If a traffic class (including all traffic in higher classes than itself) exceeds its bandwidth threshold, it is demoted in priority until it falls below the threshold again. Hence, if there is no competing traffic, any traffic class can use the full link bandwidth, but it is always possible for new traffic in a different class to start up.

The bandwidth threshold is tracked using the same algorithm as in the shaper, at bandwidths which are scaled from the shaper’s overall bandwidth setting. Packets are not actually delayed at this layer; the actual transmission time is merely checked against the deficit schedule. Priority itself is implemented using a Weighted Deficit Round Robin scheme, with the weight of each class depending on whether its threshold is exceeded or not.

The progression of the bandwidth thresholds is roughly inverse to priority. As with DRR++ (below), the assumption is that more latency-sensitive traffic generally requires less bandwidth, and that there is a fundamental tradeoff between priority and bandwidth which is required for network stability. Enforcing that tradeoff in this manner should encourage applications to choose an appropriate DSCP for their traffic, rather than lazily applying the highest available priority for “maximum” performance.

Flow Isolation

This was the original core of Cake, inheriting the basic design of fq_codel’s flow isolation scheme. It consists of a hash function over the 5-tuple flow identifier to distribute packets to a large number of queues, and a scheme similar to “DRR+“:http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mike_MacGregor/publication/3867218_Deficits_for_bursty_latency-critical_flows_DRR/links/54a20b700cf256bf8baf7c61.pdf to choose which queue to service. A separate set of queues and DRR+ state is provided for each traffic class.

Cake’s DRR++ scheme uses two lists of active queues. Newly active queues are placed in the “new flow” list, which is served with strict priority over the “old flow” list. After servicing, queues are always placed in the “old flow” list. Queues found to be empty on servicing are removed from the active lists. This relatively simple scheme naturally prioritises “sparse” flows over “bulk” flows, on the assumption that latency-sensitive traffic is likely to be sparse.

A major enhancement in Cake over fq_codel is replacement of the plain hash function with an 8-way set-associative version. Plain hashes are susceptible to the “birthday problem” in which the probability of hash collision reaches 50% when the table occupancy reaches the square root of the table size (32 flows for 1024 queues), assuming a high-quality hash; we have also found that the hash function fq_codel relies on is suboptimal.

In the set-associative hash, the set of queues is divided into sets of 8 ways. Ways are tagged with the flow identifier last assigned to them, allowing hash collisions to be detected and avoided if another way in the same set is available; either already tagged for the correct flow, or empty and inactive. This is similar to the way set-associative caches in CPUs work.

Active Queue Management

Cake uses a variant of the CoDel AQM, instantiated for each flow-isolation queue. This arrangement is again inherited from fq_codel, but subsequently modified for improved performance. The major changes to date are:

  • The count variable now saturates rather than wrapping, and thus handles overload conditions far better. These are most likely seen with unresponsive and anti-responsive flows with a high packet rate.
  • The target and interval parameters are auto-tuned based on the shaper bandwidth. Target is never less than 1.5 MTUs’ link occupancy, and Interval is never less than 8 times target. This improves throughput on slow links (under 1Mbps), and has been tested successfully down to 64Kbps. At higher bandwidths, target defaults to 5ms and interval to 100ms; these are also the defaults for standard CoDel.
  • When the dropping state is rapidly left and re-entered, count is halved rather than decremented. This improves the long-term stability of the signalling frequency.
  • Entering drop state now depends on how quickly the sojourn time is increasing. This effectively gives interval a 6:1 dynamic range around its nominal value, rather than a fixed value. Hence response to TCP’s rapid slow-start growth is sharpened and to slow congestion-avoidance growth is dulled.
  • CoDel can now be instructed to ignore ECN capability by the packet-management layer, in case of an out-of-control queue length; it will then drop instead of marking, and mark the following packet instead (if it is ECN capable). This improves robustness against maliciously unresponsive flows and ECN washing.

Packet Management

In addition to the four major layers, there are a number of miscellaneous functions which are grouped here for convenience:

  • Maximum queue length in bytes (not packets) is dynamically calculated based on shaper bandwidth.
  • Queue overflow is handled by dropping from the head of the longest queue. The active queue lists are used to optimise search time.
  • Downstream packet encapsulation can be accounted for, both as a constant overhead and as ATM cell quantisation.
  • GRO/GSO aggregates are peeled into individual MTU-sized packets when appropriate. This greatly improves flow isolation on Ethernet hardware with excessively aggressive aggregation.

Configuration

Sensible defaults are provided for every aspect of Cake’s configuration. There are no mandatory parameters. All parameters can be specified using a single ‘tc’ invocation, and most parameters can be updated without losing packets using tc’s “change” command.

In many cases, it is only necessary to set Cake’s “bandwidth” parameter, which sets up the shaper layer and performs auto-tuning in several other places. If omitted, the shaper is set to infinite bandwidth (zero time per byte) and thus effectively disabled. This can be made explicit by specifying the “unlimited” keyword instead.

The priority-queue layer is configured using the “besteffort” (disables it), “precedence” (legacy mode, 8 classes), “diffserv8” and “diffserv4” keywords. The default, described above, is “diffserv4”.

The flow-isolation layer is configured using “flowblind” (disables it), “hosts” (ignores protocol and port fields), “dsthost” (uses only destination address), “srchost” (analogous), and “flows” (default, uses entire 5-tuple).

The AQM layer has no configuration options. However, it is planned to add simple tuning options for different prevailing RTTs that may be significantly different from the Internet-scale 100ms currently assumed. Satellite links tend to impose longer RTTs, and enclosed LANs tend to have much shorter RTTs.

Encapsulation compensation has a rich set of shortcut keywords, corresponding to typical ADSL and VDSL configurations and straightforward variants thereof. The “overhead” parameter and ATM compensation flag (“atm” vs. “noatm”) can also be specified directly. Overhead compensation is turned off completely with the “raw” keyword, and the “conservative” keyword sets up a quick-fix, with ATM cells and a full cell of overhead, for where the actual overhead is uncertain.

Statistics

Cake produces a rich set of statistics detailing the performance of the various algorithms, and this can also be used to infer information about the traffic passing through it. Simply run tc -s qdisc.

As of the ‘fishcake’ release, the statistics for each traffic class are:

  • rate - the priority layer’s threshold bandwidth.
  • target and interval - the AQM layer’s tuned parameters.
  • Pk/Av/Sp delay - the peak, average and sparse-flow delays experienced by recent packets. These are tracked using biased EWMAs.
  • pkts - the total number of packets sent.
  • way inds/miss/cols - the set-associative hash reports ‘indirect hits’, ‘misses’ and ‘collisions’ whenever it needs to search the set. All other packets are ‘direct hits’ and are not directly counted.
  • bytes - total bytes sent.
  • drops and marks - number of packets dropped (by AQM or queue overflow) and ECN-marked (by AQM).

Additional statistics are planned in the near future, which will require enlarging the stats struct and breaking compatibility with existing versions of userspace code (tc).

To edit this page, submit a pull request to the Github repository.
RSS feed

Recent News & Articles

Dec 27, 2016 Wiki page
RRUL Chart Explanation
Jul 4, 2016 Wiki page
Getting SQM Running Right
Nov 19, 2015 Wiki page
CakeFAQ

Find us elsewhere

Bufferbloat Mailing Lists
#bufferbloat on Twitter
Google+ group
Archived Bufferbloat pages from the Wayback Machine

Sponsors

Comcast Research Innovation Fund
Nlnet Foundation
Shuttleworth Foundation
GoFundMe

Bufferbloat Related Projects

Congestion Control Blog
Lede Project (OpenWrt)
Flent Network Test Suite
Sqm-Scripts
The Cake shaper
AQMs in BSD
IETF AQM WG

Network Performance Related Resources


Jim Gettys' Blog - The chairman of the Fjord
Toke's Blog - Karlstad University's work on bloat
Voip Users Conference - Weekly Videoconference mostly about voip
Candelatech - A wifi testing company that "gets it".